[Editor’s note: This one is by my brother Chris Gaddis, who covers CU basketball for BuffsBlog. Chris is the optimist in the family. Then the Buffs lost at home to Portland, and it turns out even Chris has limits.]
Colorado trailed by 13 at halftime, went 5-of-31 from three and lost 77-74 at home to Portland. Chris Gaddis on the slow starts, the empty seats and a bar we all miss.
Top photo: Boulder’s world-famous (and now gone) Dark Horse Bar and Grill.
There are losses. And then there are “let’s bulldoze the Dark Horse to make room for condos none of us can afford” type losses. Colorado’s 74-77 home defeat to the Portland Pilots on Wednesday night falls squarely into the second category.
The Buffs entered the season hoping to establish themselves as a competitive Big 12 program. I predicted they would. Five games in, they’re 2-3, have already lost at home (more on the so-called home-court advantage in a minute), and are displaying some disturbingly familiar characteristics of Tad Boyle teams from the past three years. Inconsistent effort, questionable shot selection, and an uncanny ability to make mediocre opponents look like Final Four contenders.
Yes, Colorado nearly erased a 13-point halftime deficit. Yes, Justin Neely was outstanding. And yes, the Buffs had two opportunities to force overtime in the closing seconds. But celebrating a comeback against Portland misses the larger point. It’s Portland. At home. And there’s no Dark Horse nearby in which to drown our sorrows.
Another First Half, Another Hole
At some point, slow starts stop being an unfortunate coincidence and become a defining characteristic. Colorado has now trailed at halftime in four consecutive games. Four. In a row.
Against Portland, the Buffs fell behind 4-17 before most fans had settled into their seats. The Pilots, apparently unaware they were supposed to be intimidated by a Big 12 opponent playing at altitude, proceeded to shoot 50% from the field and put up 44 first-half points. Colorado, meanwhile, managed one made three-pointer in nine attempts.
Boyle’s postgame assessment was revealing: “We didn’t play with the effort we needed to play in the first half.” Well, that’s a problem. We’re five games into the season. Effort shouldn’t be something a team discovers in the locker room at halftime, particularly when that team is playing at home against an opponent it should beat.
And when the same pattern repeats itself four games in a row, it becomes fair to question whether the issue is preparation, leadership, or simply a roster that hasn’t figured out how to play together. Whatever the explanation, it’s getting old.
When in Doubt, Shoot Another Three
Let’s address the elephant in the room. Colorado attempted 31 three-pointers Wednesday night. It made five. Five. That’s 16.1%, which is a pretty impressive accomplishment if the objective was to test the structural integrity of the CU Events Center’s rims.
Now, there’s nothing inherently wrong with taking 31 threes in modern college basketball. But when the shots aren’t falling, at some point somebody needs to recognize that perhaps another approach might be worth considering. Attack the basket. Get to the free-throw line. Find something resembling a high-percentage shot. Instead, the Buffs kept firing.
My favorite sequence came early in the second half when Inman, who was having his worst shooting night of his career (0-7 from three), launched a deep three from the left wing. The ball caught the front of the rim and bounced right back to him, still standing behind the arc. A second chance. A fresh opportunity to reconsider his options on the worst shooting night of his career. Nope. Inman promptly fired another three, this one sailing over the basket without touching anything. Two shots. Zero points. One possession. If at first you don’t succeed, apparently shoot from the exact same spot again.
Even Colorado’s most reliable scorer, Barrington Hargress, was a shell of himself against the Pilots. Hargress entered Wednesday averaging 19.5 points per game, including a 33-point performance against San Diego State. Against Portland, he managed three points on 1-of-5 shooting, missing both three-point attempts. Three points. From your leading scorer. Hargress is too talented to disappear offensively, and Colorado simply isn’t good enough to overcome that kind of performance, particularly on a night when the rest of the team couldn’t hit water from a boat.
The bigger concern isn’t simply that Colorado had a miserable shooting night. Those happen. It’s whether this roster has enough reliable perimeter shooting to compete in the Big 12. Because if Portland can make Colorado look this uncomfortable offensively, I shudder to think what Houston might do.
Thank Goodness for Justin Neely

If there was a bright spot Wednesday, it was Justin Neely. The Colorado forward delivered 27 points and nine rebounds, his best performance as a Buffalo in both categories. He was aggressive, physical, and willing to take responsibility when much of the offense appeared to be operating without a plan. Noah Feddersen added 14 points, while Jalin Holland contributed 12.
But let’s not confuse Neely’s individual brilliance with a particularly encouraging team performance. Colorado increasingly looks like a team waiting for somebody to rescue it offensively. Wednesday, that somebody was Neely. Against better competition, that isn’t going to work. Neely can be a difference-maker. He shouldn’t have to be the entire difference.
Portland? Seriously?
Before going any further, credit where credit is due. Portland came into Boulder, played with confidence, and deserved to win. Jaxon Olvera overcame some terrible tattoos to lead the Pilots with 22 points. RJ Nance added 14 off the bench, and Hunter Adam contributed 13, including three made three-pointers. And when Colorado opened the second half with a 10-0 run, Portland responded with eight straight points of its own. That’s what good teams do. They respond.
But let’s also remember who we’re talking about here. Portland entered Wednesday’s game coming off a double-overtime home loss to East Texas A&M. East. Texas. A&M. A team from the Southland Conference had just scored 94 points against these same Pilots. This wasn’t Kansas. It wasn’t Houston. It wasn’t Arizona. It was Portland, a West Coast Conference program that Colorado should be able to handle on its home floor.
Which brings me to another concern. For years, Boyle’s teams made Boulder a miserable destination for visiting opponents. The altitude, the students, the energy, the physicality. Winning at CU was supposed to be difficult. Colorado is averaging approximately 4,375 fans through its first three home games, down nearly 30% from last season’s 6,207 and almost 38% from two years ago. The once-intimidating CU Events Center is beginning to resemble a particularly spacious high school gym. Apparently, the fans have figured out something the basketball program hasn’t: You have to give people a reason to show up.
The Big 12 Is Coming. Ready or Not.
Five games is a small sample size. I’m not ready to write off the season, and I still believe this team has enough talent to be competitive. But the warning signs are becoming difficult to ignore. The Buffs can’t seem to start games with any urgency. Their perimeter shooting is inconsistent at best. Their defensive effort comes and goes. And offensively, they seem far too dependent on somebody having a career night.
Those problems aren’t going to disappear when conference play begins. They’re going to get worse. Big 12 opponents aren’t going to politely allow Colorado to sleepwalk through the first 20 minutes before mounting an inspirational comeback. Houston won’t. Arizona won’t. Kansas won’t. And if we’re being realistic, neither will most of the conference.
Boyle has built his reputation on toughness, rebounding, and defense. Those have been the foundation of his best Colorado teams. Wednesday, we saw flashes of all three in the second half. Unfortunately, basketball games last 40 minutes.
The Buffs don’t need to become a perfect basketball team overnight. But they do need to establish a few non-negotiables. Play hard from the opening tip. Defend somebody. Take better shots. And perhaps most importantly, stop waiting until you’re down double digits to decide the game matters. None of that seems particularly complicated.
Where Do We Go From Here?
Colorado now sits at 2-3 with Stanford waiting on November 24 in the Acrisure Series. A game that looked like another early-season opportunity to build momentum suddenly feels considerably more important.
There’s still plenty of basketball left to play. Boyle has turned teams around before, and I wouldn’t bet against him figuring out how to get more out of this group. But I’m also not going to pretend Wednesday was just another early-season hiccup. Losing at home to Portland is bad enough. Doing it while displaying the same problems that have plagued this program in recent seasons is considerably worse.
I predicted this team would be competitive in the Big 12. I still want to believe that. But at some point, the Buffs need to give us something more than a spirited second-half comeback against an opponent they had no business trailing in the first place.
The question isn’t whether Colorado can play 20 minutes of good basketball. We’ve seen that it can. The question is whether this team can put together 40 minutes of winning basketball. Five games in, I’m still waiting.
And frankly, I could use a beer at the Dark Horse.
More BuffsBlog You Might Have Missed

The Dead, the Buffs, and the Art of Getting High
Chris on the San Diego State loss, and why he still thought the Buffs would be fine.

An Optimist’s Preview of the CU Buffs: Why This Team Might Be Better Than You Think
The preseason case for a competitive Big 12 team.

Coming Attractions: 24 of ESPN’s Top 100 Basketball Players Are on the Buffs’ Schedule
Chris on who is coming to Boulder this season, and who the Buffs have to go see.

Thanks Chris. I’m afraid it’s going to be another long season at the CU Events Center.
At least we have JR Payne and the women’s team!
On this same night, CU’s women’s team went to The Pit in New Mexico and beat down the Lobos. JR Payne knows how to bring a team with a lot of portal players into a team-first culture and HAVE FUN, whereas Tad Boyle’s teams look like they played terrified of Tad Boyle.
Great article!! I think Tad has lost his touch. We have talent and the crew should be having more success. It is hard to watch at times. It will still be fun to watch some Big 12 hoops this season in Boulder though!